Chronic hypertension (CHTN) affects 1-1.5% of all pregnant women and approximately one third require antihypertensive medications (meds) before pregnancy or during the first 20 weeks of gestation.
To determine breastfeeding (BF) initiation rates of women with CHTN and their association with pregestational body mass index (BMI kg/m2).
Retrospective study of 111 women with CHTN requiring meds and 206 with CHTN not requiring medication (without meds) who delivered at ≥ 34 weeks of gestation. Intention to BF exclusively or partially was declared prenatally. At discharge, exclusive BF, partial BF and formula feeding (FF) were determined.
CHTN-meds and without meds groups were similar in primiparity (41 & 46%), superimposed preeclampsia (23 & 21%), intention to exclusively BF (91 & 87%), vaginal delivery (56 & 61%), GA at delivery (38 & 38 weeks), late preterm (16 & 14%) and admission to NICU (17 & 16%). These groups differed in maternal age (32 & 30y) and black race (22 & 34%). At discharge, exclusive BF (50 & 47%), partial BF (32 & 35%), FF (18 & 17%) and BF initiation (82 & 82%) were similar among groups. Comparison between 130 women with BMI 30-39 (obese) and 146 with BMI ≥ 40 (morbidly/extremely obese) showed vaginal delivery to be less common (67 & 47%) and primary cesarean to be more frequent (17 & 32%) among the latter group. At discharge, both groups were comparable in exclusive BF (48 & 47%), partial BF (34 & 35%), FF (18 & 18%) and BF initiation rate (82 & 82%).
BF initiation rates for women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds were similar. Morbid obesity did not negatively affect BF initiation rates.
Chronic hypertension (CHTN) affects 1-1.5% of all pregnant women and may lead to adverse maternal and neonatal outcomes [1-3]. The prevalence of CHTN in pregnancy has increased more than ten-fold in the US since 1970 and coincides with an increase in obesity, type 2 diabetes and advanced maternal age [4-6]. Due to severity of illness, one third of women with CHTN require antihypertensive medications (meds) before the onset of pregnancy or starting during the first 20 weeks of gestation [1-3,7]. According to current guidelines, antihypertensive medications should be reserved for women with severe hypertension or with specific renal or cardiovascular co-morbidities [1-3]. CHTN is associated with obesity, superimposed preeclampsia, cesarean delivery, cardiovascular disease, placental abruption, fetal growth restriction and maternal and perinatal death [1,3,8,9]. Adverse neonatal outcomes include indicated preterm delivery, cesarean birth, poor fetal growth, preeclampsia and neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) admission [3,8,9].
Hypertensive disorders during pregnancy, particularly those complicated by preeclampsia, have long-term and possibly permanent consequences for mothers and their infants [10,11]. Recent guidelines encourage BF among women with CHTN because most commonly used antihypertensive medications are found in low concentrations in breast milk [1-3,12]. Lactation has been recognized to provide short- and long-term health benefits to mothers and their infants following healthy pregnancies as well as those compromised by different co-morbidities [3,13-16]. In spite of the above, information on BF initiation among women with CHTN remains scarce.
To compare BF initiation among women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds. A secondary objective was to compare BF initiation rates among subclasses of obese women with CHTN.
This retrospective cohort investigation was approved by the Institutional Review Board at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center. Electronic maternal and neonatal records (2016-18) were reviewed. CHTN was defined as hypertension diagnosed before conception or at < 20 weeks of gestation in the current pregnancy according to established clinical and laboratory criteria [1-3]. Indications for treatment of CHTN with medication were in accordance with established ACOG guidelines [1-3]. Women were categorized by body mass index (BMI) as normal (18-24.9 kg/m2), over weight (25-29.9 kg/m2), obese (30-39.9 kg/m2), morbidly obese (40-49.9 kg/m2) and extremely obese (≥ 50 kg/m2).
The study population consisted of women with CHTN who intended to BF (exclusively or partially) at discharge and their singleton infants delivered at ≥ 34 weeks gestation. Pregnancies affected by diabetes mellitus or major fetal malformations were not included. Upon arrival to labor and delivery, each woman described her past BF experience and her intention to BF. Our family-centered care system has rooming-in available and full-time lactation consultants whose services are offered to all women regardless of their infant feeding preference.
Per our hospital practice, any symptomatic infants were directly transferred from the delivery room to the NICU for further care. If the condition of the mother and her infant following delivery allowed, maternal-infant interactions such as holding, skin-to-skin contact, and BF were encouraged. Asymptomatic infants able to feed were transferred to the newborn nursery for routine care and glucose monitoring if applicable. Delivery room and postpartum maternal-infant interactions were observed and documented by the obstetrical, newborn nursery and NICU nursing staffs and by lactation consultants.
Screening for hypoglycemia (blood glucose < 40 mg/dl) was done via serial point of care testing (Accu-Chek®) or by plasma glucose measurement in the laboratory (Beckman Coulter AU5800, Beckman Coulter Inc., Brea, CA, U.S.A.) starting within the first hour of life after the first feeding and every 2-4 hours thereafter as needed. Asymptomatic infants in the newborn nursery with hypoglycemia were promptly BF or formula fed (FF) and those with recurrent hypoglycemia were treated with intravenous (IV) dextrose. On admission to the NICU, most infants were started on IV dextrose and those who were able to feed were BF or FF.
BF was considered initiated if, during the 24 hours preceding hospital discharge, infants were BF exclusively or BF partially. Exclusive BF was defined by direct feedings from the breast, by expressed breast milk (EBM) alone or in combination with direct BF or by donor human milk. Partial BF was defined by direct BF or EBM in combination with FF. Due to the retrospective study design, no follow-up information was available on infant feeding practices after hospital discharge.
Comparisons between women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds were made with two-sample t-tests for continuous variables and Chi square tests for categorical variables. Significance was established at a p value < 0.05. A secondary analysis was designed to ascertain clinical and demographic characteristics and BF outcomes of 130 obese (BMI 30-39.9 kg/m2) and 146 morbidly and extremely obese (BMI ≥ 40 kg/m2) women with CHTN.
The study population consisted of 317 women with CHTN (111 CHTN-meds and 206 CHTN without meds).
Clinical and demographic characteristics of women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds are shown in Table 1. Most variables were similar between the groups although mother's age was higher and the percent of black women were lower in the CHTN-meds group. Consistent with the diagnosis and treatment of women in the CHTN-meds group, the most common medications prescribed were labetalol 74 (67%), nifedipine 9 (8%), amlodipine 9 (8%), metoprolol 9 (8%), methyldopa 8 (7%) and carvedilol 2 (2%). At discharge from the hospital, 95% of women from the CHTN-meds and 15% of those in the CHTN without meds groups received oral antihypertensive medications.
Table 1: Comparison of women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds. View Table 1
CHTN with superimposed preeclampsia affected 23% women with CHTN-meds and 21% with CHTN without meds. All women with CHTN with superimposed preeclampsia with severe features received 24 hours of postpartum intravenous magnesium sulfate for seizure prophylaxis.
Smoking during pregnancy (6 & 10%) was similar between the CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds groups. However, history of smoking (22 & 13%) was more common among the CHTN without meds group. The rates of vaginal deliveries (56 & 61%), primary cesarean (23 & 23%) and repeat cesarean (21 & 16%) were similar between groups.
Neonatal outcomes of infants born to women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds are shown in Table 2. Outcomes between the groups were comparable in the incidence of late prematurity (16 & 14%), admission to NICU (16 & 16%) and infant length of stay (3 ± 2 & 4 ± 4d). Considering the similarities in diagnoses, 18 infants from the CHTN-meds group and 33 infants from the CHTN without meds group admitted to the NICU were combined for analysis. Of these 51 infants, 27 (53%) were full-term and 24 (47%) were late preterm. NICU admission diagnoses included respiratory distress (29%), temperature instability-hypotonia-poor feeding (33%), apnea-bradycardia-cyanosis (20%), hypoglycemia (10%), neonatal abstinence syndrome (4%) and miscellaneous (4%). Fourteen of the 51 infants (27%) stayed in the NICU for less than one day and seven (14%) infants stayed two days. Among the 317 infants of the CHTN groups combined, there were 33 (10%) small for gestational age (SGA), of them only seven were admitted to the NICU. All 317 mothers and their infants were discharged home in good condition.
Table 2: Neonatal outcomes of infants born to women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds. View Table 2
The percent of multiparous women with CHTN in either group were similar (59 & 54%). Relevant to our study, prior BF experience among them was also comparable (70 & 78%). Intention to exclusively BF was similar among women with CHTN-meds (85%) and women with CHTN without meds (85%).
Immediate transfer of symptomatic infants to the NICU was required by 13% of the CHTN-meds and 12% of the CHTN without meds group. During the first two postpartum hours the following mother-infant interactions were recorded: BF (68 & 67%) and skin-to-skin contact without BF for the remaining dyads. At the end of the hospital stay, (82 & 82%) women of either CHTN group had BF at least once.
Further analysis of mode of delivery on early BF showed that among 187 women from both groups combined who delivered vaginally, 142 (76%) were able to BF within two hours of birth while only 72 of 130 (55%) of infants delivered by cesarean were able to BF within two hours of birth (p 0.0002). Over time, however, these differences did not persist since at discharge, 153 of the 187 (82%) infants born vaginally and 108 of 130 (83%) of those born by cesarean had initiated BF. Of note, at discharge, exclusive BF was also similar for women who delivered vaginally and for those who delivered by cesarean (50 & 47%).
At the time of discharge the rates of exclusive, partial BF, FF and BF initiation were similar between the two groups (Table 3). Four of the 13 dyads in the CHTN-meds group and 6 of the 18 CHTN without meds group received exclusive EBM while in the remaining instances, EBM complemented direct BF. Nine of the 56 (16%) infants in the CHTN-meds group and 17 out of 97 (18%) in the CHTN without meds group that BF exclusively at discharge received formula supplementation during their hospital stay. Two infants in the CHTN-meds group and four in the CHTN without meds group received donor human milk during their hospitalization. Lactation consults were given to all women in either group with the median number of consultations per dyad being 2 (range 1-6).
Table 3: BF at discharge for women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds. View Table 3
The entire population of 317 women was divided into groups according to pregestational BMI as follows: 5 (2%) normal, 36 (11%) overweight, 130 (41%) obese, 101 (32%) morbidly obese and 45 (14%) extremely obese. Comparisons of clinical and demographic characteristics of 130 obese and 146 morbidly/extremely obese women combined are shown in Table 4. CHTN-meds occurred with similar frequency in both groups (38 & 32%). The incidence of superimposed preeclampsia was also similar (23 & 23%). Other comparable characteristics were primiparity (39 & 48%), mothers age (31 & 31y) as well as advanced maternal age (23 & 20%). Vaginal delivery was less common (47 & 67%) and primary cesarean (17 & 32%) was more common among women in the morbidly/extremely obese BMI group. At discharge, both groups were comparable in exclusive BF (48 & 47%), partial BF (34 & 35%), FF (18 & 18%) and BF initiation rate (82 & 82%).
Table 4: Breastfeeding initiation among women with CHTN according to pregestational Body Mass Index. View Table 4
CHTN is a common medical complication of pregnancy and approximately one third of women require antihypertensive medications before conception or during the first 20 weeks of gestation and beyond [1-3]. The rate of CHTN during pregnancy across the world continues to rise in parallel to the obesity epidemic and increasing maternal age [1,5,6,17]. The severity of hypertension among women with CHTN-meds in our study seems validated by their almost universal need for antihypertensive treatment before, during and beyond discharge from the hospital [1,2,7,12].
Rates of preeclampsia, cesarean delivery, preterm birth, admission to the NICU and disorders of fetal growth noted here are comparable to that reported by others [8,9,18]. The similarities of the maternal and neonatal outcomes in this investigation may be suggestive of the benefits of antihypertensive treatment of women with more severe CHTN, however, additional randomized trials are needed to determine the benefit of antihypertensive therapy in women with moderate hypertension in pregnancy [1,2,7]. Earlier studies have shown that in some instances, antihypertensive treatment may reduce the risk of severe hypertension without visible changes in the rates of adverse perinatal outcomes [3,7]. The incidence of preeclampsia reported here 23% for CHTN-meds and 21% for those in the CHTN without meds group is comparable to that reported by others [8,11,19]. Not surprising, the incidence of cesarean delivery increases in relation to the severity of superimposed preeclampsia on CHTN. In our study, primary cesarean rate among 248 women with CHTN was 20%, whereas the rate among 69 CHTN with superimposed preeclampsia was 34%.
Short term benefits of BF among infants and children of healthy women or those challenged by high risk obstetrical conditions have been documented [19-23]. There is growing evidence that lactation has short- and long-term cardiovascular health benefits for women [13,15]. An early study of duration of BF on the incidence of maternal hypertension showed that women who never BF had an increased incidence of hypertension in later years compared to those who BF six months or longer . Recently, a systematic review of four cross-sectional studies reported that history of lactation lowered the odds of hypertension among women of middle to old age . Hypertensive disorders during pregnancy, in particular preeclampsia, may have long term and possibly permanent consequences for motor development in the offspring [22,23].
Intention to BF is one of the strongest predictors of BF initiation in healthy as well as high risk obstetrical populations [20,21,24]. Despite the heterogeneity of morbidities and co-morbidities associated with high risk obstetrical pregnancies including CHTN, intention to BF remains comparable to that of the general population . Unfortunately, a discordance exists among women with complex pregnancies between their intention to BF and their actual rate of BF initiation at the time of discharge [20,21,24]. There are many recognizable obstacles to BF initiation including lack of intention to BF, gestational and pregestational diabetes, preeclampsia, maternal obesity, cesarean delivery, premature birth, mother-infant separation, admission to the NICU and infant morbidities that lead to lower BF initiation rates [16,20,21,24,26].
Our finding that women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds who intended to BF had a BF initiation rate of over 80% (exclusive or partial BF) at discharge is significant because it compares favorably with that of the general healthy maternal population . However, this success is tempered by the fact that only half of women from either CHTN group were able to exclusively BF their infants at the time of discharge well below the mandate of a national regulatory agency .
Both the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine recommend exclusive BF for all healthy infants during birth hospitalization and beyond [28-30]. However, these organizations acknowledge that other nutritional options may be needed to temporarily replace or supplement BF under well-defined circumstances (i.e., maternal and neonatal illness, late preterm infants). Healthcare providers must be aware that delays associated with some morbidities will further the need for alternatives to exclusive direct BF [28-30]. Due to their clinical condition or to the separation from their sick or prematurely born infants, not all women with CHTN-meds or CHTN without meds are able to BF shortly after birth. In that case, our practice is to provide mother's milk if obtained antenatally, EBM if tolerated, donor human milk if feasible or infant formula if prescribed by a physician [27,29].
It is well known that milk expression by hand or with an electrical pump may help mothers overcome obstacles to early BF and therefore increase BF duration [31-35]. In line with current literature, it is hoped that women who direct BF with or without EBM at discharge would continue to provide exclusive or partial BF. On the other hand, feeding exclusively by EBM is concerning since available reports are pessimistic about BF duration following hospital discharge [34,35]. Several investigators concurred that exclusive EBM feeding should be recommended for full-term and premature infants only when medically necessary and not as a substitute for feeding directly from the breast [33,34].
Obese women, even those without CHTN, are more likely to have complicated labors, cesarean deliveries and separation from their infants postpartum [21,26,36]. It has been reported that obese women have less intention to BF, lower rates of BF initiation and shorter duration of exclusive and any BF [16,36]. Several years ago, in a study of 360 non-diabetic obese women who delivered macrosomic infants, we reported that intention to BF was similar for obese/very obese (75 & 73%) but it was lower (61%) for morbidly obese and that BF initiation was 71%, 66% and 53%, respectively . We later realized that BF initiation rates were so low because like others, we included in our study populations both women who intended to BF as well as those who intended not to BF. Considering that women who do not intend to BF seldom change their mind and will exclusively FF their infants, in this investigation we included only women who intended to BF exclusively or partially [21,24,36]. As a consequence, the data presented here showed that BF initiation was higher among women who intended to BF and highlighted the obstacles that prevented some of them from achieving their desired BF goal.
In normal as well as in high risk pregnancies certain hospital practices may delay infant feeding (i.e., cesarean delivery, eye prophylaxis, vitamin K administration, blood glucose monitoring). While some of these practices may be postponed, others may be unavoidable especially in women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds who delivered prematurely. Cesarean delivery, a traditionally recognized obstacle to early mother infant interactions, occurs frequently among women with CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds [1,2,8,26,37,38]. Earlier, we reported that cesarean delivery increased from 38% among obese to 57% among those extremely obese . In the present study, we observed 33% cesarean deliveries among 130 obese/very obese and 53% cesarean deliveries among 146 morbidly/extremely obese women with CHTN.
Cesarean delivery, in some cases, is known to prevent or delay skin-to-skin contact, postpone the first BF, reduce the possibility of exclusive BF and increase the likelihood of formula supplementation [37-39]. Our data, however, showed that among women with CHTN who intended to BF, the impact of a delay in early BF associated with cesarean delivery could be overcome with healthcare provider's commitment to BF, multidisciplinary education and support of patients and families.
Limitations to this investigation are those inherent to the retrospective design and the lack of follow-up information regarding infant feeding after discharge. We also recognize that a uniform threshold for initiating antihypertensive therapy can only be established with a treatment trial. Also, the definition of BF initiation at discharge may be applicable only to women with high risk obstetrical conditions for whom early mother-infant contact may be delayed. The strength of this investigation rests on the size of the obstetrical and neonatal population and the fact that the data were obtained directly from contemporaneous medical records, and not via post-delivery maternal questionnaires.
In conclusion, infants born to women with both CHTN-meds and CHTN without meds are at a higher risk for premature birth and concurrent morbidities that often require admission to the NICU leading to temporary mother-infant separation. Intention to BF predicts better BF initiation rates, however, exclusive BF at discharge in women with CHTN fell short of the expected direct BF goal, raising concerns about long term BF duration. Due to severity of illness, treatment side effects and infants' morbidities, dyads affected by CHTN who are not ready for early direct BF, can be helped by temporary alternatives such as EBM and donor human milk. Additionally, the high rate of partial BF during their hospital stay may identify women who are still striving toward exclusive BF at discharge and who, with specific support and guidance, might achieve their intended goal.