Table 4: Observer concordance and 2 × 2 table values for Extended ASL cohort with both 3.0 T and 1.5 T systems. Observer concordance is defined as in table 1. The left 2 × 2 table is for the entire extended cohort of ASL studies, while the right table is censored, excluding 5 study results that were ambiguous, i.e., outcome was not be definitive by the study's end.

A

Observer concordance
Overall agreement Fleiss' free margin kappa Complete agreement Partial discordance (1 v. 2 or 2 v. 3) Complete discordance (1 v. 3)
ASL total 76% 0.69 52/75
69%
23/75
31%
0/70
0%
ASL censored 80% 0.7 49/70
70%
21/70
30%
0/71
0%

B

ASL extended cohort
Cond. + Cond. - Sum PPV, NPV
Test + 14 4 18 0.78
Test - 8 49 57 0.86
Sum 22 53 75
Sens., Spec. 0.64 0.92 0.84

C

ASL extended cohort censored
Cond. + Cond. - Sum PPV, NPV
Test + 14 2 16 0.88
Test - 8 46 54 0.85
Sum 22 48 70
Sens., Spec. 0.64 0.96 0.86