Table
1: Study populations included in this meta-analysis of sun
sensitivity, sunburns and melanoma among populations of Spanish descent.
Author, Publication Year |
Age Range |
Place |
Diagnosis Datesa |
Case/ Control |
Casesb |
Controls |
Report Quality scoresc |
Rodenas,
1996 |
Cases: 20-79 Controls: 21-78 |
Spain, Andalusia |
1989-1993 |
105/138 |
All incident in-situ or invasive
melanomas from the dermatology department at the University of Granada
Hospital |
Randomly selected visitors to
patients other than dermatology ward without any other acute disease |
12 |
Espinosa Arrenz,
1999 |
Cases: 21-87 Controls: 21-84 |
Spain, Madrid |
(1/1990-1/1994) |
116/235 |
Consecutive melanomas from
dermatology and plastic surgery for oncology department at the La Paz,
Hospital |
Randomly selected emergency
patients unrelated to cancer or skin; age & sex matched |
7 |
Loria, 2001 |
Not stated |
Argentina, Buenos Aires City |
5/1993-3/1995 (6/1993-4/1995) |
101/246 |
All in-situ and invasive melanomas
from 4 hospitals in Buenos Aires City |
Randomly selected hospital
controls, age, sex, and hospital matched (non-dermatology illnesses) |
7 |
Ruiz Lascano,
2004 |
Cases: 14-87 |
Argentina, Cordoba |
(12/1998-12/2001) |
65/195 |
Consecutive melanomas from the
dermatology service of the Hospital Privado de
Cordoba |
Randomly selected medical clinic
patients (non-dermatology), age and sex matched |
5 |
Fernandez, 2007 [2009] |
Not stated |
Spain, Madrid |
(09/1/2004-09/30/2005 [10/3/2007]) |
116/188 [205/245] |
Consecutive melanomas from the dermatology
department of Gregorio Maranon general University Hospital |
Cancer free subjects from Madrid
College of Lawyers, age and sex matched |
6 |
Nagore,
2009 |
Cases: 60-96 Controls: 60+ |
Spain, Valencia |
1/1/1998-12/31/2006 |
160/318 |
Consecutive in-situ and invasive
melanomas from dermatology dept. of Instituto Valencianco de Oncolgia (IVO) |
Age 60+ randomly selected among
those evaluated between 2002-2004 in Program Of Health Promotion; age and sex
matched |
8 |
Ballester,
2012 |
Cases:43-69 Controls: 42-64 |
Spain, Valencia |
Treatment 1/2007-6/2008 |
242/173 |
All incident melanomas treated in
dermatology departments in 5 hospitals in Valenica |
Individuals accompanying
non-melanoma patients to dermatology departments from the same geographic area
excluding relatives |
6 |
aStudies that reported data collection dates rather than
diagnosis dates are in parenthesis.
bUnclear if in-situ and/or invasive cases unless otherwise
specified. All studies reported histologically confirmed melanomas.
cReport Quality assessment was based on four
5-point scales for: completeness of 1) types of cases and controls selected; 2)
cases description and 3) control description describing how recruited, reasons
for eligibility and numbers at stages of recruitment; and 4) for adequate
description of how potential confounders were identified and how they were
chosen with a low score for not stating anything or moderately low for using
p-values to determine confounding.