Table 1: General description of studies.

Study

Study design, types of cancer outcome  and type of exposure

Confounders

No. of Subjects/population

Source of data

Baumgardt-Elms [56]

Case control, morbidity, testicular, occupational

Matched by age and region

1066

Clinical and pathology departments in  5 regions in Germany, Interviews

Berg [57]

Case control brain tumors, occupational

Age, gender (matched), socioeconomic status, urban vs. rural area, ionizing radiation, smoking, cell phone, demographic characteristics, transmitters and ham radio, smoking and medical histories, occupational exposure to EMF

2241

 

Interviews, questionnaire.

Four neurological clinics in Germany,

population registries

Calle [58] Letter

Proportional mortality ratio, leukemia, occupational

Adjusted for age and year of death

6 radio and telegraph operators (observed)

Wisconsin Department of Health and Social Services

Cantor [46]

Case control, mortality, breast cancer, occupational

Adjusted for age and socio economic status

108,989 white women, 16,033 black women

National Cancer Institute, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) and the National Center for Health Statistics

Chung –Yi [41]

Ecological morbidity, all site cancers, leukemia and brain tumors, environmental

Age, gender, ELF,  calendar year of diagnosis, urbanization level of township

2606 including 939 leukemia and 394 brain cancer

National health Insurance Research Database, Taiwan National Communication Council

Coleman [59]  Letter

Proportional registration ratio(PRR), leukemia, occupational

5-year age group, adjusted for age

8 cases of telegraph/radio operators

South-East England, South Thames Cancer Registry

Cooper [60]  Letter

Ecological, morbidity, leukemia, environmental

Stratified by 5-year age bands, gender and socioeconomic status

20 leukemia cases

West Midlands Cancer Intelligence Unit database (Birmingham, England)

Degrave [35]

Cohort mortality, all types, occupational

Age

7349

Military, Belgian National Registry, Belgian National Cancer Registry

Davis [61]

Cohort, morbidity, testicular, occupational

Testes disease or trauma, family history of testicular cancer, occupational exposure to pesticides and herbicides

340 police officers

Interviews, SEER 1981 registry rates. Pathology slides

Demers [62]

Case control, morbidity, breast cancer, occupational

Age, work history, a broad range of risk factors (not detailed), education

527 total, 12 communication and broadcasting exposure, males 

Cancer registries and National Cancer Institute,

Interviews

Dode [31]

Ecological mortality, all site cancers, environmental

Age, gender

7191

Health Department of the city Belo Horizonte in Brazil, Brazilian Telecommunication Agency, Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics

Dolk [63]

Ecological, morbidity, all types, environmental

Age, socioeconomic  class

408,000 males and females

National Statistics office UK, cancer registry,

British Broadcasting Corporation.

Population and cases were located via postcode of residence

Dolk  [64]

Ecological, morbidity, leukemia, melanoma, bladder, childhood leukemia and brain, environmental

Age, socioeconomic status

3.39 million males and females

National Statistics office UK, cancer registry, British Broadcasting Corporation.

Population and cases were located via postcode of residence

Eger [16]

Case control morbidity, all types, environmental

Age, gender

1000

Medical records

Elliot [65]

Case control,

Brain and CNS, leukemia, non Hodgkin's and all cancers, environmental

Gender, date of birth, education, deprivation measure, population density, population mixing

6985 children

All  the registered cases of cancer in children aged 0-4 in Great Britain in 1999-2001. Four national mobile phone operators provided data

Finkelstein [66]

Cohort morbidity all types, occupational

Age, calendar year

12 leukemia cases,  41 melanoma cases

Ontario cancer registry, 83 Ontario police departments

Goldsmith [47] analysis of Lilienfeld  1978

Cohort mortality, all site cancers, leukemia, breast, brain,

occupational

Not stated

 

Lilienfeld 1978

Goldsmith [36] analysis of Robinette  1980

Cohort mortality all types, occupational

Year of birth

40,000 Korean war Naval personnel

Navy and Veterans Administration records

Goldsmith [47] analysis of

Anderson 1986

Ecological morbidity, All site cancers and leukemia, environmental

Age

1143 cases of all site cancers in males and females

26 leukemia cases in males and females

Honolulu Cancer Registry, EPA radiation measurements

 

Grayson [67]

Nested case control, morbidity brain tumors, occupational

Age, race, military rank as a surrogate for socioeconomic status. Cases and controlled were matched

1150 males

US Air Force personnel records

Groves [68]

Cohort mortality, all types, occupational

Age

40,581 total

20,021 high exposure, males

Department of Veterans Affairs.

Job classification from US Navy Veteran cohort, industrial hygienists

Ha [45]

Ecological, morbidity, all site cancers, breast, leukemia, lymphoma, brain cancer, environmental

Age

3152 -126,523  people per area

 

Clinical and pathology departments in  5 regions in Germany, Interviews

Ha [42]

Case control morbidity, leukemia and brain tumors, environmental

Matched on age, gender and year of diagnosis.

Residential location, population density and

socioeconomic status, industrialized environmental pollution

5966 children (up to 15 years old)

South Korean Medical Insurance Data system, National Cancer Registry

Hardell [69]

Case control, testicular, occupational

Selection of the closest subjects in birth registration number (born in the same year)

462 total

5 radar workers

Swedish Cancer Registry

Hayes [70]

Case control, morbidity, testicular, occupational

Age, radioisotopes, radioactive materials or nuclear materials, pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

530 males

Three collaborating medical institutions in Washington DC area, two of the study hospitals were military hospitals

Hocking [71]

Ecological, morbidity and mortality, children and adults, leukemia and brain tumors, environmental

 

Age, gender, calendar period, area

585,000 males and females

New South Wales Cancer Registry (Australia), Commonwealth Department of Communication and Arts

Hocking [39]

Survival ecological, leukemia, environmental

Age, gender and year of diagnosis

160 children

New South Wales (Australia) cancer registry

Holly [72]

Case control, morbidity Uveal melanoma, occupational

Demographic characteristics, occupational history, and exposure to chemicals.

Excluded home microwave ovens

668 males

Ocular Oncology Unity at the University of California San Francisco, interviews

Karipidis [73]

Case control, morbidity non Hodgkin's lymphoma, occupational

Matched on age, gender and area of residence. Occupational exposure, risk factors of NHL, ionizing radiation, chemicals

1388 males and females

 

New South Wales Central Cancer Registry, Australia.

New South Wales and Austrian Capital Territory electoral polls

Karipidis [74]

Case control, Morbidity Glioma, occupational

Age, gender, postcode of residence. Occupational exposure, education.

Job exposure matrix included exposures to ELF, RF, UV and ionizing radiation

838

 

14 Melbourne hospitals, Victoria Cancer Registy,   major population centers in the state of Victoria, Australia. Questionnaires and interviews

Kliukiene [75]

Nested case control within a cohort, morbidity breast cancer, occupational 

Job histories, Match on year of birth, exposures

495 within a cohort of 2619

National cancer registry of Norway

Lagorio [30]

Cohort mortality, all site cancers, leukemia, brain, Digestive, liver, lung, breast, occupational

Age, gender, calendar period – specific regional mortality rates to the person years at risk

481 females

Registry Office of the municipalities

Maskarinec [76]

Case control morbidity, leukemia, environmental

Age, gender, medical history, exposure to metals, smoking in the home, X rays, proximity to oil drums, parents occupational history and exposure to metals, chemicals. Case and controls were matched on gender and age

60 cases and controls, children

Hawaii Tumor Registry, Interviews

Mcdowall  [27] Letter

Proportional mortality ratio (PMR), leukemia, occupational

-

6 telegraph radio operators (no. of cases)

Office of population censuses and surveys, England and Wales electrical occupations

McKenzie [77]

Ecological, leukemia  morbidity, environmental

Age and socioeconomic status

216 children

New South Wales Central Cancer Registry

Merzenich [78]

Case control morbidity, leukemia, environmental

Age, gender and transmitter area (matching), population density

7807

 

German childhood cancer registry (1984- 2003)

Michelozzi [79]

Ecological, mortality, morbidity, childhood and adult leukemia, environmental

Age, gender, socioeconomic class

49,656 adults and children

Lazio Region Geographic information mortality system, Italian Cancer Registries, main hospitals in Rome, Residence data: local population register, and census tract

Milham [29] Letter

Proportionate mortality ratio (PMR), leukemia, occupational

Standardized by age and year of death

5  radio and telegraph operators, 5  TV and radio repairman, no. of observed

All deaths of Washington State. Washington State department of Social and Health Services

Milham [80]

Proportionate Mortality Ratio (PMR), leukemia, lymphoma, lung, brain, pancreas, occupational

Age, year of death

486,000 males total

Records of male deaths filed in Washington State

Milham [81] Letter

Proportionate mortality ratio (PMR), leukemia occupational

Age

1691 male deaths. Of them 24 with leukemia

Washington State and California, radio operators monthly magazine that lists deaths on monthly basis

Milham [82]

Cohort mortality, all types, occupational

Age

67,829 amateur radio operators

US Federal Communications Commission Amateur Radio Station and/or Operator License file from the National Technical Information Services

Milham [26]

Cohort, mortality, Hematologic, lymphatic and brain cancer,

occupational

Age

67,829 amateur radio operators

US Federal Communications Commission Amateur Radio Station and/or Operator License file from the National Technical Information Services

Morgan [83]

Cohort, mortality, brain, lymphatic/hematopoietic, Hodgkin's,

melanoma, respiratory system, stomach, breast, occupational

Age, gender, race

195,775 total

24,621 exposed

National Death Index, Social Security Administration, archived personnel files

Pearce [84]

Case control morbidity, leukemia, occupational

Matched on Age and year of  registration 

6   radio/TV repair, males

New Zealand cancer registry

Pearce [85]

Case control, morbidity, leukemia, occupational

Age

12  radio/TV repair, males

New Zealand Cancer Registry

Szmigielski [37]

Cohort, morbidity, all types, occupational

Age, diagnosis date

128,000 total

3,700 exposed, males

Military's health departments, hospitals, medical board, safety groups operating as health hygienic service 

Szmigielski [38]

Cohort morbidity all types, occupational

Age

124,500 total, about 3500-4500 exposed males

Polish army, service records listing of exposures

Thomas [86]

Case control, mortality, brain tumor, occupational

Educational level, match on age at death, year of death and area of residence. Risk factors of brain tumor

821death certificates, males

Northern New Jersey, Philadelphia, PA, and southern Louisiana.

Brain tumors verified through a hospital record review

Tynes [87]

Cohort morbidity, all types, occupational

Sea related lifestyle factors: A diet rich in fat, artificial light, disturbances in the geomagnetic field, alcohol

2619 females

National Cancer Registry of Norway

Wolf [17]

Cohort morbidity all sites, environmental

Socioeconomic class employment status, demographic heterogeneity due to differences in age gender and ethnicity

1844

Medical clinics, national and city incidence rate

Wright  [28] Letter

Proportional Incidence Ratio (PIR) leukemia, occupational

Specific for age, gender and race

1 no. of cases (TV and radio repair)

Cancer Surveillance Program information on

Los Angeles County