Table 2: Summary of findings table including relative effect measure, absolute effect measure, and certainty of evidence.
Outcome |
Study results and measurements |
Absolute Effect Estimates |
Certainty in effect estimates (quality of evidence) |
|
NMBAs |
No NMBAs |
|||
All-cause mortality
|
aRR 0.84 (0.74 to 0.95) Based on data from 3,351 patients in six studies |
603/1691 (35.7%) |
673/1660 (40.5%) |
Moderate due to serious inconsistency |
5 fewer per 1,000 (from 105 fewer to 20 fewer) |
||||
Health-related quality of life by EQ-5D-5L
|
bMD 0.02 lower Based on data from 246 patients in one study |
127 |
119 |
Low due to very serious imprecision |
|
||||
Adverse events
|
aRR 0.80 Based on data from 4,627 patients in four studies |
265/2333 (11.4%) |
270/2294 (11.8%) |
Low due to serious imprecision and inconsistency |
24 fewer per 1000 |
||||
Organ failure free days to day 28 by system |
bMD 1.65 higher |
657 |
641 |
Very low due to very serious imprecision and inconsistency |
|
||||
Improvement PaO2/FiO2
|
bMD 11.02 higher |
1900 |
1737 |
Low due to serious imprecision |
|
||||
Days free of ventilation at 28 days
|
bMD 0.67 higher |
737 |
724 |
Low due to very serious imprecision |
|
||||
Days not in the hospital
|
bMD 0.15 higher |
127 |
119 |
Very low due to serious inconsistency and very serious imprecision |
|
Abbreviations: NMBAs: Neuromuscular blocking agents; CI: Confidence interval; RR: Risk ratio; MD: Mean difference. aRisk Ratio (95% confidence interval). bMean difference (lower to higher).